Want to know why men won't
commit?
Your mother probably could
have told you.
The No. 1 reason, according
to some Rutgers University researchers, is that
it's easy to get sex without marriage these days.
Of course, there's slightly
more to it than that. The young men interviewed
by the National Marriage Project were also afraid
of divorce - particularly its financial
consequences - and they were reluctant to make
the changes and compromises marriage entails.
They experience little social pressure to marry.
And they want a "soul mate" they've yet to meet.
The men questioned, who were 25 to 33 years old,
were in no hurry to have children.
The study released yesterday
is part of a continuing exploration of marriage
by the National Marriage Project, headed by
sociologist David Popenoe and Barbara Dafoe
Whitehead, a social historian and analyst. The
two are avowedly pro-marriage. "We think it's an
important social institution and it's especially
important for children," Whitehead said.
The Marriage Project also
released an update of "The State of Our Unions,"
an annual compilation of data on marriage trends.
The group interviewed 60
never-married, heterosexual, employed men in
northern New Jersey, Chicago, Washington and
Houston. Most had at least some college education
and incomes that ranged from $21,000 to $35,000.
When asked if they were men whom women would
want to marry, Popenoe said, "A lot of them
were, yeah."
These were focus groups,
which Whitehead conceded are "highly
unscientific." The results of their discussions
will help the Marriage Project formulate
questions for a broader survey next year.
Other tidbits gleaned from
the conversations that women might find
interesting: Men are turned off by women who
openly want children or already have them; they
view women they meet in bars as casual sex
partners rather than marriage material; and
they're more likely to "take it slow" with a
woman they see as a potential long-term partner.
(That means waiting to have sex until the fourth
or fifth date.) They want a wife who works.
It doesn't take long to find
men with similar attitudes in Philadelphia. A
quick walk through Center City at lunch hour
yesterday turned up guys saying the same sorts of
things Whitehead and Popenoe heard, although they
didn't volunteer that easy sex is what keeps them
from buying a ring.
Sandwiched between two
older, married coworkers on a shaded wall,
23-year-old computer programmer Chris DeFrancesco,
of Turnersville, Gloucester County, said he's not
thinking about marriage at all, despite the fact
that he's been with his girlfriend 10 months.
"I'm not enticed by the
whole thing," he said. "It seems like nowadays
it's more like a business contract." If you get
divorced, he said, "you lose half your stuff."
Some of his older friends, he said, caution him
against getting married, saying their wives spend
too much of their money.
Coworkers Andrew Tappata, 38
and married nine years, and Tim Tyler, who, at
42, is seven years into his second marriage, both
said they would recommend that DeFrancesco wait.
"I think 27 is a good age,"
said Tappata, of Langhorne, Bucks County.
"Thirty's even better," said
Tyler, of Gulph Mills, Montgomery County. "The
younger you are, you get married for the wrong
reason."
Ron Szott, a 33-year-old
carpenter from Philadelphia, said, "I just
haven't met the right girl." He'd also like to be
financially secure. "Everyone wants the house
first," he said, "the Beemer [BMW] in the
driveway."
Commitment is an issue
because the age of marriage is creeping upward.
The average age at first marriage is at an
all-time high for this country - 25 for women and
27 for men.
"The men are waiting longer
and longer, and it's virtually costless to them,"
Popenoe said. Meanwhile, women, who face a
deadline for childbearing, are in a "totally
different situation." Popenoe worries that, if
trends continue, more women will have children
alone or marry less-desirable partners.
"I think it's going to be
very disadvantageous for women and children," he
said.
Of course, later marriage is
not entirely bad. Teenage marriages are
notoriously unstable. Whitehead thinks the
optimum age for marriage is between 25 and 35.
Popenoe would put it at 25 to 30, adding that he
thinks "you shouldn't marry before 25."
Popenoe said he's concerned
that people who wait too long become too set in
their ways, too attached to their independence.
Popenoe, 69, who has been
married more than 40 years, said one of the
things that struck him was how many of the young
men wanted soul mates. "They were looking for a
person who was not going to hassle them one bit,"
he said with a chuckle. "That was their idea of a
soul mate."
Whether it was a sign of
already being stuck in their ways or simply being
men is open to debate, but the men in the focus
groups clearly resented women who wanted them to
change.
"Women look at men like
computers; they always want to upgrade," one
complained.
Popenoe and Whitehead think
a key reason for later marrying is the trend
toward living together. The number of unmarried
couples living together increased from 439,000 in
1960 to 4.7 million in 2000.
"Cohabitation gives men
regular access to the domestic and sexual
ministrations of a girlfriend while allowing them
greater legal, social and psychological freedom
to lead a more independent life and to continue
to look around for a better partner," they wrote.
Whitehead said young women
need to be aware of men's attitudes. If a larger
study shows that men don't consider long-term
relationships with women who have sex on the
first date, she said, "it seems like that would
be something useful to know."
And they need to know they
might be out of sync with men.
"At a certain point in
women's lives, they've been there, done that, and
they're shifting over to looking for a life
partner," she said. They tend to hit that point
sooner than men.
Women, Popenoe said, "have
to think seriously about the fact that the man's
time schedule is completely different from
theirs." That may mean they decide more quickly
whether relationships have long-term promise and
move on if they don't.